I would prefer not to pay $50k+ a year to keep this guy in prison in the US, but it’s a tough call. You send him home, he gets out and comes back to the US in a few years without ever serving time. Honduras doesn’t want him either so they won’t be much help.
This is one reason why we have to increase border security whether it be a wall or whatever. Your boy Obama’s “catch and release” policy is what got Jim kidnapped.