eagleswoodville#1 Posted October 20, 2014 Report Posted October 20, 2014 My list: 1. Joe Montana 2. Peyton Manning 3. Brett Favre 4. John Elway 5. Terry Bradshaw Soooo many other great ones though: Steve Young Jim Kelly Brett Favre Tom Brady Roger Staubach Troy Aikman Dan Marino Kurt Warner Warren Moon Fran Tarkenton Bart Starr Otto Graham Let me know your opinion on the subject!! Quote
TxHoops Posted October 20, 2014 Report Posted October 20, 2014 Always a great topic. My list: 1) Montana 2) Elway 3) Brady 4) Unitas 5) Manning Qualifiers - I reluctantly put Johnny U on the list because I believe he was the best before the current era. Watching old footage, the talent level was not even close to today's game so it's tough to compare apples and oranges. If Peyton wins another one, I would move him to at least 3 and maybe 2. Quote
eagleswoodville#1 Posted October 20, 2014 Author Report Posted October 20, 2014 Always a great topic. My list: 1) Montana 2) Elway 3) Brady 4) Unitas 5) Manning Qualifiers - I reluctantly put Johnny U on the list because I believe he was the best before the current era. Watching old footage, the talent level was not even close to today's game so it's tough to compare apples and oranges. If Peyton wins another one, I would move him to at least 3 and maybe 2. It was very hard for me to not out Johnny U on the list. Ultimately I decided not because of the talent level difference. And Peyton, with the records he ready holds, is at least top 3 IMO. If he wins 2 more bowls and surpasses Brett Favre's all-time yards mark, he jumps to #1 easy. Quote
mytwocents-28 Posted October 20, 2014 Report Posted October 20, 2014 And Peyton, with the records he ready holds, is at least top 3 IMO. If he wins 2 more bowls and surpasses Brett Favre's all-time yards mark, he jumps to #1 easy. ^^^^this!!!!!! Quote
TxHoops Posted October 20, 2014 Report Posted October 20, 2014 It was very hard for me to not out Johnny U on the list. Ultimately I decided not because of the talent level difference. And Peyton, with the records he ready holds, is at least top 3 IMO. If he wins 2 more bowls and surpasses Brett Favre's all-time yards mark, he jumps to #1 easy. I would jump him to 1 too with two more Super Bowls. I have him where he is now due to his perfomances in the "big" games. Brady has in my mind done more with less in the trophy and SB departments. That's why I have him higher. To me, the game is about winning and that's why Montana is 1 and I would probably barely have Marino in my top 10. Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.