Brady> Manning.

[king]

Can we please, please put the Brady vs. Manning debate to rest already??

Great players win big games, they don't melt under the lights against inferior competition.

[PhatMack19]

I agree. Manning has seemingly always better talent around him on offense and couldn't do as much as Brady. Brady has a huge advantage with Belicheck though.

[king]

the colts started his career, and tonight ended it

[Eazy]

Manning will be 39 and Brady 38 before next season. Manning is probably done. Brady could play a couple of more years.

[Mr. Buddy Garrity]

the colts started his career, and tonight ended it

Post of the night about Peyton. Sad ending. 

[bullets13]

His career is over if he wants it to be over. He's still better than most of the qbs in the league. He might not be good enough to win a Super Bowl, but I guarantee you the broncos will take him back, and 15 or more teams on top of that.

[NDNation]

Took the Broncos to the SB last year, and went pretty far this year. Who would fill his shoes? Manning doesn't seem like a greedy guy, when he feels he's then he's done.

[Gabe]

9 times Manning one and done in playoffs. No other qb has more than 4. That is not good and many of those he had bye week before with home field.

[Peppermint Patty]

I'll give him a waiver for this year. That's a tough injury.

 

http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2015/01/12/report-peyton-manning-has-a-torn-right-quadriceps/related/?utm_network=twitter&utm_post=3324260&utm_source=TW%20%40NBCSports&utm_tags%20=

[mat]

Rogers and Romo were both playing with injuries too.

 

Payton could win another super bowl but he can't carry a team to a super bowl win.

[king]

Manning had Demaryious Thomas,Julios Thomas, Wes Welker,Emmanuel Sanders!

Brady only had Gronkowski, and JULIAN EDELMAN. Edelman would barely make the depth chart and Brady still out performs him.