mat Posted January 30, 2022 Report Share Posted January 30, 2022 14 minutes ago, LCMAlumtiger32 said: Arnt you Orangefield fan? No. LCM and WOS. I’ll route for Orangefield and other locals. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Tiger33 Posted January 30, 2022 Report Share Posted January 30, 2022 3 hours ago, mat said: No. LCM and WOS. I’ll route for Orangefield and other locals. Did you graduate from LCM ? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
mat Posted January 30, 2022 Report Share Posted January 30, 2022 10 hours ago, LCMAlumtiger32 said: Did you graduate from LCM ? No, Stark High Tiger33 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Cougar14.2 Posted January 31, 2022 Report Share Posted January 31, 2022 On 1/27/2022 at 1:27 PM, Reagan said: Actually, your statement, "pushed out by your current administration" was NOT an arbitrary fact statement on your part. It was a pretty definite statement. OK, so you admit you don't know. I thought you did by your statement and I wanted to know what you knew about it. Let me explain good and bad for you. Good: Let go because the school said the coach has had a enough time to win a State Championship. Bad: If a coach is pushed out because of a preconceived buddy deal. If I see smoke coming from the windows I don't have to run inside the house to tell you it's on fire. That's not how I would define good and bad reasons at all either. A "good" reason for being pushed out is poor job performance, personal conduct infractions or a rule violation like what happened to Jeff Nelson at Ozen. A "bad" reason would be because of administrative vendettas, town "politics" or the perceived notion that you should be competing at higher level when your personnel doesn't necessarily dictate that. Mr. Buddy Garrity, NDNation, PN-G bamatex and 2 others 4 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
AggiesAreWe Posted January 31, 2022 Report Share Posted January 31, 2022 1 minute ago, Cougar14.2 said: If I see smoke coming from the windows I don't have to run inside the house to tell you it's on fire. That's not how I would define good and bad reasons at all either. A "good" reason for being pushed out is poor job performance, personal conduct infractions or a rule violation like what happened to Jeff Nelson at Ozen. A "bad" reason would be because of administrative vendettas, town "politics" or the perceived notion that you should be competing at higher level when your personnel doesn't necessarily dictate that. THIS!!!!!!! Well said 14.2 PN-G bamatex and Cougar14.2 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Reagan Posted January 31, 2022 Report Share Posted January 31, 2022 13 minutes ago, Cougar14.2 said: If I see smoke coming from the windows I don't have to run inside the house to tell you it's on fire. That's not how I would define good and bad reasons at all either. A "good" reason for being pushed out is poor job performance, personal conduct infractions or a rule violation like what happened to Jeff Nelson at Ozen. A "bad" reason would be because of administrative vendettas, town "politics" or the perceived notion that you should be competing at higher level when your personnel doesn't necessarily dictate that. I'll ask you: Did the "personel" just show up when Surratt at Carthage (after 84 years of no State Title) and Buchanan at Aledo showed up? Of course not!! They were there before. The coach was the difference! Again, letting a coach go, it all depends on where you set the bar. My bar is high. The PNG coach had 12 years. Does that mean he was treated unfairly? I wouldn't think so. But, I knew after 7-8 years that a State Title wasn't in PNG's future. Maybe the Superintendent and board members realized the same thing. Like I've said before -- if one's expectations are low, then they'l be met EVERY time! Rez 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
PN-G bamatex Posted January 31, 2022 Report Share Posted January 31, 2022 34 minutes ago, Reagan said: I'll ask you: Did the "personel" just show up when Surratt at Carthage (after 84 years of no State Title) and Buchanan at Aledo showed up? Of course not!! They were there before. The coach was the difference! Again, letting a coach go, it all depends on where you set the bar. My bar is high. The PNG coach had 12 years. Does that mean he was treated unfairly? I wouldn't think so. But, I knew after 7-8 years that a State Title wasn't in PNG's future. Maybe the Superintendent and board members realized the same thing. Like I've said before -- if one's expectations are low, then they'l be met EVERY time! My expectations are never lower than when responding to trolls, but here goes. With respect to Aledo, the answer to your rhetorical question couldn't be more different than the one you provided. The City of Aledo more than doubled in size from 2010 to 2020. It grew by nearly 60% over the ten years prior to that, and by nearly 50% over the ten years prior to that. Aledo ISD's enrollment growth has been even faster than the city's population growth. Like the Austin suburbs, a lot of Aledo's biggest subdivision developments have cropped up outside city limits, where developers have elected to use a combination of MUDs and HOAs to establish basic services and governing structures instead of traditional, municipal options. Not to mention that the bulk of the population growth in and around Aledo has been comprised of young families; the median age in Aledo has dropped like a sinking stone. It also helps that Aledo's median household income is multiples of the state average. The community's growing like a weed because the Fort Worth suburbs keep lurching west, and the influx of talent couldn't be more clear on the field. Aledo's own local leadership will tell you their success on the gridiron is owed in large part to their explosive population growth. agrfall1970 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Reagan Posted January 31, 2022 Report Share Posted January 31, 2022 8 minutes ago, PN-G bamatex said: My expectations are never lower than when responding to trolls, but here goes. With respect to Aledo, the answer to your rhetorical question couldn't be more different than the one you provided. The City of Aledo more than doubled in size from 2010 to 2020. It grew by nearly 60% over the ten years prior to that, and by nearly 50% over the ten years prior to that. Aledo ISD's enrollment growth has been even faster than the city's population growth. Like the Austin suburbs, a lot of Aledo's biggest subdivision developments have cropped up outside city limits, where developers have elected to use a combination of MUDs and HOAs to establish basic services and governing structures instead of traditional, municipal options. Not to mention that the bulk of the population growth in and around Aledo has been comprised of young families; the median age in Aledo has dropped like a sinking stone. It also helps that Aledo's median household income is multiples of the state average. The community's growing like a weed because the Fort Worth suburbs keep lurching west, and the influx of talent couldn't be more clear on the field. Aledo's own local leadership will tell you their success on the gridiron is owed in large part to their explosive population growth. What about Carthage, Stephenville, Celina, Brownwood? You think Austin Westlake is going to replicate what Dodge has done? Southlake Carrol hasn't replicated what Dodge has done. And probably not going to. So, at Aledo, Buchanan had NOTHING to do with it?! With all the growth you talk about about, they are in Div 2 5A. So, come the 3rd, they should zoom right on up to Div 1 6A. But, Buchanan must be the luckiest coach in the world to be there at the right time when all the athletes showed up. But, the ones I feel sorry for are the previous 14 coaches that never had Buchanan's great fortune. And the worst of the lot is the coach right before Buchcnan. If he would have just stayed on all the State Championships would have been his! Even you can't believe that! But, maybe you can!! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
PN-G bamatex Posted January 31, 2022 Report Share Posted January 31, 2022 48 minutes ago, Reagan said: What about Carthage, Stephenville, Celina, Brownwood? You think Austin Westlake is going to replicate what Dodge has done? Southlake Carrol hasn't replicated what Dodge has done. And probably not going to. So, at Aledo, Buchanan had NOTHING to do with it?! With all the growth you talk about about, they are in Div 2 5A. So, come the 3rd, they should zoom right on up to Div 1 6A. But, Buchanan must be the luckiest coach in the world to be there at the right time when all the athletes showed up. But, the ones I feel sorry for are the previous 14 coaches that never had Buchanan's great fortune. And the worst of the lot is the coach right before Buchcnan. If he would have just stayed on all the State Championships would have been his! Even you can't believe that! But, maybe you can!! Where did I say Buchanan had nothing to do with it, smitty? Don’t put words in my mouth. Of course Buchanan had something to do with it. All the population growth in the world won’t help a football program if there isn’t a good coach in charge. But the quality of the coaching is just one part of a larger equation. Take the massive influx of talent entering Aledo over the last twenty years away, and Aledo wouldn’t be nearly as successful as it’s been, Buchanan or no Buchanan. Your extra examples aren’t helping your case. Celina grew more than 150% from 2010 to 2020. Celina’s median household income is even higher than Aledo’s. Stephenville hasn’t grown as quickly, but its population is still up roughly 50% since 2000. And where Stephenville, Carthage and Brownwood all differ from Aledo (and the Mid-County schools, for that matter) is that they’re all 4A-DI or below. Those classifications aren’t utterly dominated by fast growing, upscale suburban schools in the way that everything from 5A-DII up is. The disparity in talent, funding, resources, socioeconomic backgrounds and so on isn’t nearly as severe. Cougar14.2 and agrfall1970 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Reagan Posted February 1, 2022 Report Share Posted February 1, 2022 36 minutes ago, PN-G bamatex said: Where did I say Buchanan had nothing to do with it, smitty? Don’t put words in my mouth. Of course Buchanan had something to do with it. All the population growth in the world won’t help a football program if there isn’t a good coach in charge. But the quality of the coaching is just one part of a larger equation. Take the massive influx of talent entering Aledo over the last twenty years away, and Aledo wouldn’t be nearly as successful as it’s been, Buchanan or no Buchanan. Your extra examples aren’t helping your case. Celina grew more than 150% from 2010 to 2020. Celina’s median household income is even higher than Aledo’s. Stephenville hasn’t grown as quickly, but its population is still up roughly 50% since 2000. And where Stephenville, Carthage and Brownwood all differ from Aledo (and the Mid-County schools, for that matter) is that they’re all 4A-DI or below. Those classifications aren’t utterly dominated by fast growing, upscale suburban schools in the way that everything from 5A-DII up is. The disparity in talent, funding, resources, socioeconomic backgrounds and so on isn’t nearly as severe. Actually you didn't say anything about the coaching. You were trying to prove why it wasn't about the coaching by saying how massive the population growth was that brought Aledo the athletes! In your last sentence, you are still giving excuses why a coach wins and why a coach loses and it's not because of the coach! So, I guess if Faircloth was lucky enough to have got the Carthage job then he, not Surratt, would have won all those State Titles. I say probably not. He had 12 years at PNG to prove he could or couldn't. We know which one it was. Can't run from ones record of no State Titles! I say again, if Surratt came to PNG, within my time frame of 7 years PNG would have at least one State Title. But, with your thought, Surratt would not ever win a State Title at PNG. Why would I say he would: Because that's what State Championship-type coaches do. But, I will grant you this: there aren't that many of these coaches out there. I'd say, maybe, 10%. That's why in 12 years Faircloth couldn't. That's why in 19 years Nuemann couldn't. And that's why in 15 years Burnett couldn't. 90% of the coaches can't. So, that's why it's easy to blame the kids/athletes! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
PN-G bamatex Posted February 1, 2022 Report Share Posted February 1, 2022 2 minutes ago, Reagan said: Actually you didn't say anything about the coaching. You were trying to prove why it wasn't about the coaching by saying how massive the population growth was that brought Aledo the athletes! In your last sentence, you are still giving excuses why a coach wins and why a coach loses and it's not because of the coach! So, I guess if Faircloth was lucky enough to have got the Carthage job then he, not Surratt, would have won all those State Titles. I say probably not. He had 12 years at PNG to prove he could or couldn't. We know which one it was. Can't run from ones record of no State Titles! I say again, if Surratt came to PNG, within my time frame of 7 years PNG would have at least one State Title. But, with your thought, Surratt would not ever win a State Title at PNG. Why would I say he would: Because that's what State Championship-type coaches do. But, I will grant you this: there aren't that many of these coaches out there. I'd say, maybe, 10%. That's why in 12 years Faircloth couldn't. That's why in 19 years Nuemann couldn't. And that's why in 15 years Burnett couldn't. 90% of the coaches can't. So, that's why it's easy to blame the kids/athletes! I’ll say it one more time. Don’t put words in my mouth. Thanks for once again verifying why I should keep my expectations low when dealing with internet trolls, smitty. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MackLewis Posted February 1, 2022 Report Share Posted February 1, 2022 3 hours ago, Reagan said: I'll ask you: Did the "personel" just show up when Surratt at Carthage (after 84 years of no State Title) and Buchanan at Aledo showed up? Of course not!! They were there before. The coach was the difference! Again, letting a coach go, it all depends on where you set the bar. My bar is high. The PNG coach had 12 years. Does that mean he was treated unfairly? I wouldn't think so. But, I knew after 7-8 years that a State Title wasn't in PNG's future. Maybe the Superintendent and board members realized the same thing. Like I've said before -- if one's expectations are low, then they'l be met EVERY time! Would Surratt duplicate that success at Orangefield? Carthage was a sleeping giant…. Much like Jasper is. Sure, it takes the right coach, and some luck to get the ball rolling and the program up and off the ground. IMO Surratt is one of the best coaches in the state, but just because he’s done it at Carthage don’t mean he would replace Danaher and won titles there. Mr. Buddy Garrity 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
refuse2lose Posted February 1, 2022 Report Share Posted February 1, 2022 3 hours ago, Reagan said: I'll ask you: Did the "personel" just show up when Surratt at Carthage (after 84 years of no State Title) and Buchanan at Aledo showed up? Of course not!! They were there before. The coach was the difference! Again, letting a coach go, it all depends on where you set the bar. My bar is high. The PNG coach had 12 years. Does that mean he was treated unfairly? I wouldn't think so. But, I knew after 7-8 years that a State Title wasn't in PNG's future. Maybe the Superintendent and board members realized the same thing. Like I've said before -- if one's expectations are low, then they'l be met EVERY time! T0M WESTERBERG 17 years; 186-34-0; 16-11-4 2004 Allen 9-3-0 R 2005 Allen 9-3-0 R 2006 Allen 13-2-0* 2007 Allen 10-1-0*2008 Allen 15-1-0* 2009 Allen 10-2-0* 2010 Allen 10-2-0* 2011 Allen 11-1-0*2012 Allen 15-1-0*2013 Allen 16-0-0*2014 Allen 16-0-0* 2015 Allen 14-1-0* 2016 Barbers Hill 8-3-0 T 2017 Barbers Hill 6-3-0 2018 Barbers Hill 7-4-0 T 2019 Barbers Hill 11-2-0* 2020 Barbers Hill 6-5-0 T If getting a State Championship coach is all that is needed why didn't Barbers Hill win one? I think Athletes play a part of it. I do agree good coaching helps the program. But some schools don't have the athletes to compete deep in the playoffs. It also comes down to depth on your roster if you have multiple players going both ways and the other team doesn't it makes things even harder. Mr. Buddy Garrity and bullets13 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Reagan Posted February 1, 2022 Report Share Posted February 1, 2022 2 hours ago, PN-G bamatex said: I’ll say it one more time. Don’t put words in my mouth. Thanks for once again verifying why I should keep my expectations low when dealing with internet trolls, smitty. WOW! Name calling! Shows your immaturity! Thanks for proving it! agrfall1970 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Reagan Posted February 1, 2022 Report Share Posted February 1, 2022 1 hour ago, refuse2lose said: T0M WESTERBERG 17 years; 186-34-0; 16-11-4 2004 Allen 9-3-0 R 2005 Allen 9-3-0 R 2006 Allen 13-2-0* 2007 Allen 10-1-0*2008 Allen 15-1-0* 2009 Allen 10-2-0* 2010 Allen 10-2-0* 2011 Allen 11-1-0*2012 Allen 15-1-0*2013 Allen 16-0-0*2014 Allen 16-0-0* 2015 Allen 14-1-0* 2016 Barbers Hill 8-3-0 T 2017 Barbers Hill 6-3-0 2018 Barbers Hill 7-4-0 T 2019 Barbers Hill 11-2-0* 2020 Barbers Hill 6-5-0 T If getting a State Championship coach is all that is needed why didn't Barbers Hill win one? I think Athletes play a part of it. I do agree good coaching helps the program. But some schools don't have the athletes to compete deep in the playoffs. It also comes down to depth on your roster if you have multiple players going both ways and the other team doesn't it makes things even harder. As I've said before -- nothing is in a straight line. But, concerning Westerberg, it's easy to point to him. But, I believe he was at BH for only 6 years. I truly believe if he stayed he would have got a State Title at BH. My opinion. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
refuse2lose Posted February 1, 2022 Report Share Posted February 1, 2022 29 minutes ago, Reagan said: As I've said before -- nothing is in a straight line. But, concerning Westerberg, it's easy to point to him. But, I believe he was at BH for only 6 years. I truly believe if he stayed he would have got a State Title at BH. My opinion. HAL WASSON 33 years; 256-125-3; 23-13-11986 Italy 8-4-0*1987 Italy 9-2-0*1988 San Saba 4-6-1 R1989 San Saba 8-3-0*1990 Pittsburg 3-7-01991 Pittsburg 3-7-01992 Kerens 7-4-0 R1993 Kerens 10-2-1 R1994 Kerens 9-2-0*1995 Mexia 9-2-1*1996 Mexia 10-2-0 R1997 Mexia 3-7-01998 Mexia 1-9-01999 Liberty Hill 3-7-02000 Liberty Hill 3-7-0 —staff, Southlake Carroll—2003 Keller Fossil Ridge 6-4-02004 Keller Fossil Ridge 6-4-02005 Keller Fossil Ridge 6-5-0 T2006 Keller Fossil Ridge 10-2-0*2007 Southlake Carroll 11-2-0*2008 Southlake Carroll 8-3-0 R2009 Southlake Carroll 11-2-0*2010 Southlake Carroll 10-4-0 T2011 Southlake Carroll 16-0-0*2012 Southlake Carroll 12-2-0*2013 Southlake Carroll 11-2-0*2014 Southlake Carroll 13-1-0*2015 Southlake Carroll 9-3-0 R2016 Southlake Carroll 10-2-0*2017 Southlake Carroll 10-4-0 T ---AD, Irving---2019 Corsicana 7-4-0 T2020 Corsicana 4-6-02021 Corsicana 6-4- lets take look at this coach. It took him 24 years to get a state championship. He even coached at Liberty hill and was unsuccessful. He went to Mexia in 1995 and they won a state championship 1989. Keller is horrible. Pittsburg has one state championship in 1980 and is pretty below average. Kerens, San Saba and Corsicana is mediocre. Now look at South Lake Carrol do you see how much his coaching improved? Do you think he changed much throughout his years of experience probably so. But the one factor is that the talent was greater in South lake than those other teams he coached at. Maybe PNG should have gave Faircloth 24 years and he could have got them a ring. But what if he goes to Sulphur Spring and wins a state championship. Will your opinion change about him? bullets13 and Mr. Buddy Garrity 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
mat Posted February 1, 2022 Report Share Posted February 1, 2022 8 hours ago, Reagan said: WOW! Name calling! Shows your immaturity! Thanks for proving it! Shoot. I’d be upset too if he called me smithy🙂 PN-G bamatex 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Cougar14.2 Posted February 1, 2022 Report Share Posted February 1, 2022 16 hours ago, Reagan said: I'll ask you: Did the "personel" just show up when Surratt at Carthage (after 84 years of no State Title) and Buchanan at Aledo showed up? Of course not!! They were there before. The coach was the difference! Again, letting a coach go, it all depends on where you set the bar. My bar is high. The PNG coach had 12 years. Does that mean he was treated unfairly? I wouldn't think so. But, I knew after 7-8 years that a State Title wasn't in PNG's future. Maybe the Superintendent and board members realized the same thing. Like I've said before -- if one's expectations are low, then they'l be met EVERY time! Yeah, they just showed up at Aledo. I watched Aledo's 1998 title game against Cuero and I didn't see one black kid on the team. Not that that part matters but somehow all of a sudden with the same 2% black population in their school you get Johnathan Gray, Jase McClellan, Jojo Earle, the Allen brothers, Jeff Carter, etc. ALL in recent years when they never had them before. Throw that in with their population explosion and Aledo is a total anomaly in the sense that their recruiting numbers look more like Arlington Martin's versus Southlake Carroll's like they should. CE King is good now. Is it because the new coach is that much better or is it because their enrollment grew by 1500 kids since they were in the district with Crosby 6 years ago? 1500 additional North Shore type kids is going to make it easier on any coach. Jon Kay has won 4 state titles in 8 years at North Shore. He might end up as the greatest high school coach ever but he's not beating Dodge, Samples, Carter and Joseph with Summer Creek's talent the way he's basically owned them while at North Shore going 11-3 in those contest. Meanwhile he's 3-5 against the Meekins brothers at Westfield. I know you don't consider them great coaches due to not having titles though. There's a huge difference between "low" expectations and realistic expectations which is where I think you're getting confused. I watched PNG play Montgomery and I would've given Montgomery a slight advantage athletically yet PNG still beat them. If PNG played Montgomery 10 times it would probably be 5-5. I watched them play Texas High the next week and the gap in athletes was more like a chasm. They could play that game 10 times and TH would probably win 9 of them. If PNG's administration can't can't objectively watch their team play and come to that conclusion then that's more on them than it is on BF. NDNation, BEARCPA, agrfall1970 and 4 others 5 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Mr. Buddy Garrity Posted February 1, 2022 Report Share Posted February 1, 2022 17 minutes ago, Cougar14.2 said: Yeah, they just showed up at Aledo. I watched Aledo's 1998 title game against Cuero and I didn't see one black kid on the team. Not that that part matters but somehow all of a sudden with the same 2% black population in their school you get Johnathan Gray, Jase McClellan, Jojo Earle, the Allen brothers, Jeff Carter, etc. ALL in recent years when they never had them before. Throw that in with their population explosion and Aledo is a total anomaly in the sense that their recruiting numbers look more like Arlington Martin's versus Southlake Carroll's like they should. CE King is good now. Is it because the new coach is that much better or is it because their enrollment grew by 1500 kids since they were in the district with Crosby 6 years ago? 1500 additional North Shore type kids is going to make it easier on any coach. Jon Kay has won 4 state titles in 8 years at North Shore. He might end up as the greatest high school coach ever but he's not beating Dodge, Samples, Carter and Joseph with Summer Creek's talent the way he's basically owned them while at North Shore going 11-3 in those contest. Meanwhile he's 3-5 against the Meekins brothers at Westfield. I know you don't consider them great coaches due to not having titles though. There's a huge difference between "low" expectations and realistic expectations which is where I think you're getting confused. I watched PNG play Montgomery and I would've given Montgomery a slight advantage athletically yet PNG still beat them. If PNG played Montgomery 10 times it would probably be 5-5. I watched them play Texas High the next week and the gap in athletes was more like a chasm. They could play that game 10 times and TH would probably win 9 of them. If PNG's administration can't can't objectively watch their team play and come to that conclusion then that's more on them than it is on BF. I need more likes. @Aggieswife @AggiesAreWe 😁 Cougar14.2, bullets13 and NDNation 3 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
1989NDN Posted February 1, 2022 Report Share Posted February 1, 2022 The recruiting coordinator at Aledo is second to none. So is the strength and conditioning/nutrition coach. It is amazing that every year Aledo has an outstanding RB and a few OL kids standing 6'4" or 6'5" and weighing 275+ lbs. It must be something in the water out there in SW Fort Worth, plus the population growth? Didn't the last QB move in from California? Was that last year or the year before? COVID move in because California paused sports? agrfall1970 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Cougar14.2 Posted February 1, 2022 Report Share Posted February 1, 2022 3 hours ago, 1989NDN said: The recruiting coordinator at Aledo is second to none. So is the strength and conditioning/nutrition coach. It is amazing that every year Aledo has an outstanding RB and a few OL kids standing 6'4" or 6'5" and weighing 275+ lbs. It must be something in the water out there in SW Fort Worth, plus the population growth? Didn't the last QB move in from California? Was that last year or the year before? COVID move in because California paused sports? To Aledo's credit, whatever they're doing out there is obviously legal since I'm sure the UIL has checked. Yes, the qb this past year was a transfer from California. Got to see him up close last year in Dallas. They also had an offensive lineman come from California a couple years earlier, he was a 6'6"/315lbs 4* that ended up signing with Michigan. I'm sure it's all a coincidence though. agrfall1970 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Horton Posted February 3, 2022 Report Share Posted February 3, 2022 On 1/31/2022 at 6:43 PM, Reagan said: Actually you didn't say anything about the coaching. You were trying to prove why it wasn't about the coaching by saying how massive the population growth was that brought Aledo the athletes! In your last sentence, you are still giving excuses why a coach wins and why a coach loses and it's not because of the coach! So, I guess if Faircloth was lucky enough to have got the Carthage job then he, not Surratt, would have won all those State Titles. I say probably not. He had 12 years at PNG to prove he could or couldn't. We know which one it was. Can't run from ones record of no State Titles! I say again, if Surratt came to PNG, within my time frame of 7 years PNG would have at least one State Title. But, with your thought, Surratt would not ever win a State Title at PNG. Why would I say he would: Because that's what State Championship-type coaches do. But, I will grant you this: there aren't that many of these coaches out there. I'd say, maybe, 10%. That's why in 12 years Faircloth couldn't. That's why in 19 years Nuemann couldn't. And that's why in 15 years Burnett couldn't. 90% of the coaches can't. So, that's why it's easy to blame the kids/athletes! Surratt is unlike any coach in Texas. He is a master mind at finding your teams weaknesses. carthage has always had the athletes just needed the best coach in Texas to make them into a consistent machine. 8 state championships and 11 semi finals appearances in 14 years. Carthage has not grown one bit since I graduated in 1974. We will have him at least 4 more years because his son will be a freshman and the next great QB and a freshmen team loaded with size and talent. Surratt and his staff could win anywhere they were at. We have been very blessed that he chose Carthage in 2007. Mr. Thornton Melon and Reagan 2 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Separation Scientist Posted February 3, 2022 Report Share Posted February 3, 2022 On 1/31/2022 at 9:03 PM, Reagan said: But, concerning Westerberg, it's easy to point to him. But, I believe he was at BH for only 6 years. I truly believe if he stayed he would have got a State Title at BH. My opinion. I respect your opinion but I don't share it at all. The program seem to regressing at the end. Shiny new buildings and lots of money for him and his family didn't translate into wins for BH. Playoff wins were few. I think he had only three wins in 5 years. Yes, I realize some see it differently but I am glad we moved on. As for PNG, BF and SS, I think its all going to work out for everybody in the end. BF might have been inwardly relieved to get away from all the drama, and TD will find PNG a great coach I am sure. agrfall1970 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
agrfall1970 Posted February 4, 2022 Report Share Posted February 4, 2022 On 1/31/2022 at 4:32 PM, PN-G bamatex said: My expectations are never lower than when responding to trolls, but here goes. With respect to Aledo, the answer to your rhetorical question couldn't be more different than the one you provided. The City of Aledo more than doubled in size from 2010 to 2020. It grew by nearly 60% over the ten years prior to that, and by nearly 50% over the ten years prior to that. Aledo ISD's enrollment growth has been even faster than the city's population growth. Like the Austin suburbs, a lot of Aledo's biggest subdivision developments have cropped up outside city limits, where developers have elected to use a combination of MUDs and HOAs to establish basic services and governing structures instead of traditional, municipal options. Not to mention that the bulk of the population growth in and around Aledo has been comprised of young families; the median age in Aledo has dropped like a sinking stone. It also helps that Aledo's median household income is multiples of the state average. The community's growing like a weed because the Fort Worth suburbs keep lurching west, and the influx of talent couldn't be more clear on the field. Aledo's own local leadership will tell you their success on the gridiron is owed in large part to their explosive population growth. Not as eloquent as Bamatex, but it's easy for a person with a good job in the western side of the Metroplex (Ft. Worth, Arlington, Grapevine, Lewisville, The H-B-E districts) to move to Aledo for football purposes and and keep the job. Not easy for a family living in Houston area to move to PN-G and continue working there. That may change in the future with work-from-home. PN-G bamatex 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
AledoAlumni Posted February 4, 2022 Report Share Posted February 4, 2022 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.