Reagan Posted February 5, 2022 Report Posted February 5, 2022 38 minutes ago, aledoalumni said: Come on, Aledoalumni -- Ol' Buc had very little to do with it. It was the massive population growth that did it for Aledo. Well --that's what some say anyway. Of course you know -- it's not me saying this! Oh, BTW -- one said the athletes started showing up when Buc got there. So... Quote
AledoAlumni Posted February 5, 2022 Report Posted February 5, 2022 58 minutes ago, Reagan said: Come on, Aledoalumni -- Ol' Buc had very little to do with it. It was the massive population growth that did it for Aledo. Well --that's what some say anyway. Of course you know -- it's not me saying this! Oh, BTW -- one said the athletes started showing up when Buc got there. So... Aledo is an attractive option for people that are moving to the Fort Worth area. Parents are willing to drive 45+ minutes to work so their kids can go to Aledo instead of living in Fort Worth. Reagan and PN-G bamatex 2 Quote
PN-G bamatex Posted February 5, 2022 Report Posted February 5, 2022 45 minutes ago, aledoalumni said: Aledo is an attractive option for people that are moving to the Fort Worth area. Parents are willing to drive 45+ minutes to work so their kids can go to Aledo instead of living in Fort Worth. Y’all have a really good crop of elected leadership up that way, too. In all my dealings with them, I’ve always been impressed with Phil King, Glenn Rogers (even though he technically moved back to the family ranch in Graham) and Kit Marshall. Quote
Cougar14.2 Posted February 5, 2022 Report Posted February 5, 2022 1 hour ago, Reagan said: Come on, Aledoalumni -- Ol' Buc had very little to do with it. It was the massive population growth that did it for Aledo. Well --that's what some say anyway. Of course you know -- it's not me saying this! Oh, BTW -- one said the athletes started showing up when Buc got there. So... Lol, on this documentary the 6’6”(Polynesian) lineman moves in and and the black kid who plays on the defensive line talks about transferring from Everman, I believe. This is the exact definition of “them just showing up” as well as goes to my 2% comment on why the numbers are skewed. PN-G bamatex, Reagan and Tiger33 3 Quote
AledoAlumni Posted February 5, 2022 Report Posted February 5, 2022 7 minutes ago, Cougar14.2 said: Lol, on this documentary the 6’6”(Polynesian) lineman moves in and and the black kid who plays on the defensive line talks about transferring from Everman, I believe. This is the exact definition of “them just showing up” as well as goes to my 2% comment on why the numbers are skewed. I'm not interested in talking about the race of high school kids. What I will point out is the mutual benefit for the families and programs when talented kids move in to play sports. Reagan, dme1111, navydawg31 and 1 other 4 Quote
Raider4 Posted February 5, 2022 Report Posted February 5, 2022 On 1/29/2022 at 10:32 AM, mat said: How do you know what they’re paying him? It’s public record for administration Quote
Reagan Posted February 5, 2022 Report Posted February 5, 2022 5 hours ago, aledoalumni said: 1978 6-4-0 150- 90 Mike Sneed 1979 6-4-0 134- 60 Mike Sneed 1980 3-7-0 105-220 Mike Sneed 1981 C 4-7-0 219-234 Mike Sneed 1982 5-5-0 207-152 Mike Sneed 1983 2-8-0 128-242 John E. Roberts 1984 8-2-0 236- 99 John E. Roberts 1985 1-9-0 100-216 John E. Roberts 1986 6-4-0 164-149 John E. Roberts 1987 R 6-5-0 338-252 Chuck Curtis 1988 R 8-3-0 368-140 Chuck Curtis 1989 3-7-0 106-251 Curtis or Rick Page 1990 1-9-0 52-270 Rick Page 1991 4-6-0 144-253 Steve Reid 1992 3-6-1 137-259 Randy Ewers 1993 2-8-0 69-277 Tim Buchanan 1994 6-3-1 227-153 Tim Buchanan 1995 6-3-1 191-134 Tim Buchanan 1996 R- 11-2-1 390-206 Tim Buchanan 1997 C-- 14-1-0 602-187 Tim Buchanan 1998 C-- 13-1-0 383-110 Tim Buchanan 1999 CO 10-3-0 346-169 Tim Buchanan 2000 C-- 11-1-0 409-100 Tim Buchanan 2001 R 8-4-0 331-147 Tim Buchanan 2002 R- 12-2-0 359-186 Tim Buchanan 2003 TH 10-4-0 358-167 Tim Buchanan 2004 R- 11-4-0 490-257 Tim Buchanan 2005 TH 8-6-0 398-290 Tim Buchanan 2006 TRI 12-2-0 546-146 Tim Buchanan 2007 TH 11-3-0 542-184 Tim Buchanan 2008 C-- 11-1-0 459-124 Tim Buchanan 2009 C-- 15-1-0 644-253 Tim Buchanan 2010 C-- 16-0-0 780-217 Tim Buchanan 2011 C-- 14-2-0 885-354 Tim Buchanan 2012 C-- 10-2-0 519-133 Tim Buchanan 2013 C-- 16-0-0 1,023-147 Tim Buchanan 2014 C-- 15-1-0 770-290 Steve Wood 2015 C-- 13-2-0 714-171 Steve Wood 2016 C-- 16-0-0 855-286 Steve Wood 2017 C-- 15-1-0 705-214 Steve Wood 2018 C-- 16-0-0 809-209 Steve Wood 2019 C- 15-1-0 815-319 Tim Buchanan 2020 C- 13-1-0 691-325 Tim Buchanan 2021 C- 12-1-0 712-173 Tim Buchanan WOW, Aledoalumni, this is why this clip is called "Titletown: The House That Buc Built!" Check the before and after Buchanan win/loss records since 1978. Impressive!! Since the beginning in 1946, and up until Buchanan got there, there were "only" 4 times Aledo won over 10 games. 4 times!! Plus, you got to throw Steve Wood in there. He also has Elite Coaching status! His record is: 75-4 with 3 State Championships. Heck, if PNG was smart, I'd think they would make a play for Steve Wood! Quote
Cougar14.2 Posted February 6, 2022 Report Posted February 6, 2022 On 2/4/2022 at 8:33 PM, aledoalumni said: I'm not interested in talking about the race of high school kids. What I will point out is the mutual benefit for the families and programs when talented kids move in to play sports. I don’t care about the race of kids either. I was just pointing out a once rural town on the west side of cattle country has a higher hit rate than North Shore in a certain demographic. It’s an anomaly that probably nobody else in the state can copy. There’s no more benefit at Aledo than there is at Arlington Martin who sends more kids D1 in every sport and produces better college players. The statistics just are what the stats is are. PN-G bamatex 1 Quote
AledoAlumni Posted February 8, 2022 Report Posted February 8, 2022 On 2/6/2022 at 8:24 AM, Cougar14.2 said: There’s no more benefit at Aledo than there is at Arlington Martin who sends more kids D1 in every sport and produces better college players. What do you mean "theres no more benefit"? That part has me confused. Quote
Cougar14.2 Posted February 8, 2022 Report Posted February 8, 2022 49 minutes ago, aledoalumni said: What do you mean "theres no more benefit"? That part has me confused. Your post said "mutual benefit for the families and programs when talented kids move in to play sports". I'm saying there isn't more benefit for a talented kid moving to Aledo than there is Arlington Martin. Schools are relatively the same, Martin plays better competition and produces more players that live up to their star rating when they hit college. If I was a parent of a good football player in that area that's where I would want my kid to play unless there was some other incentive to move to Aledo. Aledo isn't really great at any other boys sports besides football so obviously those are the only players moving in. Much like some college programs were ahead of the curve when it came to the NIL stuff, Aledo has been ahead of the curve on legally acquiring football talent. Quote
AledoAlumni Posted February 8, 2022 Report Posted February 8, 2022 56 minutes ago, Cougar14.2 said: Your post said "mutual benefit for the families and programs when talented kids move in to play sports". I'm saying there isn't more benefit for a talented kid moving to Aledo than there is Arlington Martin. I definitely disagree with that. Personal preference but quality of living is much higher in Aledo. Not being in a big city with a bunch of different high schools, rangers ball park, cowboys stadium, 6 flags, waterpark, ect and all that traffic. Plus you have a much better chance of team success at Aledo than Martin regarding football. Parents want there kids in a great academic school and a sports program that is going to make a deep playoff run. Aledo doesnt need to recruit. Our situation is attractive for people considering moving to the Fort Worth area. PN-G bamatex, PNGFaithful, Reagan and 1 other 3 1 Quote
PN-G bamatex Posted February 8, 2022 Report Posted February 8, 2022 8 minutes ago, aledoalumni said: I definitely disagree with that. Personal preference but quality of living is much higher in Aledo. Not being in a big city with a bunch of different high schools, rangers ball park, cowboys stadium, 6 flags, waterpark, ect and all that traffic. Plus you have a much better chance of team success at Aledo than Martin regarding football. Parents want there kids in a great academic school and a sports program that is going to make a deep playoff run. Aledo doesnt need to recruit. Our situation is attractive for people considering moving to the Fort Worth area. I’d also add that Aledo very likely has a cheaper cost of living, even accounting for the much higher median income level. AledoAlumni 1 Quote
Reagan Posted February 9, 2022 Report Posted February 9, 2022 3 hours ago, aledoalumni said: I definitely disagree with that. Personal preference but quality of living is much higher in Aledo. Not being in a big city with a bunch of different high schools, rangers ball park, cowboys stadium, 6 flags, waterpark, ect and all that traffic. Plus you have a much better chance of team success at Aledo than Martin regarding football. Parents want there kids in a great academic school and a sports program that is going to make a deep playoff run. Aledo doesnt need to recruit. Our situation is attractive for people considering moving to the Fort Worth area. One of the posters has used the word legal or legally, I think, twice when it comes to Aledo gaining athletes. Am I missing something that in the past Aledo was accused of doing something illegally? Quote
AledoAlumni Posted February 9, 2022 Report Posted February 9, 2022 5 hours ago, Reagan said: One of the posters has used the word legal or legally, I think, twice when it comes to Aledo gaining athletes. Am I missing something that in the past Aledo was accused of doing something illegally? Nope. He is just being dramatic. Reagan 1 Quote
Cougar14.2 Posted February 9, 2022 Report Posted February 9, 2022 21 hours ago, aledoalumni said: I definitely disagree with that. Personal preference but quality of living is much higher in Aledo. Not being in a big city with a bunch of different high schools, rangers ball park, cowboys stadium, 6 flags, waterpark, ect and all that traffic. Plus you have a much better chance of team success at Aledo than Martin regarding football. Parents want there kids in a great academic school and a sports program that is going to make a deep playoff run. Aledo doesnt need to recruit. Our situation is attractive for people considering moving to the Fort Worth area. That's definitely a personal preference. I think Arlington is better for exactly all the reasons you just named. Everything is right there without having to drive all the way across Ft. Worth to do anything like you do from Aledo. If more people agreed with you then more athletes besides good football players would move there, that 2% would've risen significantly and Arlington wouldn't be growing faster than Aledo. Entire families would move there and stay instead of just living there while the player goes to school. Crosby has a kid who ended up being the top scorer in the state last year transfer to play on the basketball team and we're far from a powerhouse. We have individual/relay state champions in track and have since the '80s. Does Aledo's basketball team suck because only football parents think the standard of living or academics are better there? What about your track team? I get sending them to the best academic school you can afford but 4* players don't end up there for the math classes. Katy doesn't recruit either but for the last 15 years they've ended up with a 4* back on their roster when they don't produce talent at that rate at any other position. I'm sure the running back transfer from South Carolina powerhouse Dutch Fork they used to beat North Shore the last time they won was just a coincidence? You're never going to convince me parents with star football players are going pass up schools like Euless Trinity, which is the same distance from Ft. Worth as Aledo, to come there for a couple extra playoff games or the debate team. Like I said though, however the players end up there is obviously above board so more power to y'all. Quote
Cougar14.2 Posted February 9, 2022 Report Posted February 9, 2022 23 hours ago, PN-G bamatex said: I’d also add that Aledo very likely has a cheaper cost of living, even accounting for the much higher median income level. They have a higher median income because Arlington ISD has 60k kids in their district and encompasses the type neighborhoods that the star players that end up at Aledo would normally come from. Including the entire area skews the numbers like they would for Houston Stratford and Lamar that encompass the Memorial and River Oaks areas. I do agree that your money goes further in Aledo than it does the upscale neighborhoods in Arlington but the reason people pay the premium is for access and proximity which is exactly why AA is saying people wouldn't move there and come to Aledo instead. Quote
Cougar14.2 Posted February 9, 2022 Report Posted February 9, 2022 20 hours ago, Reagan said: One of the posters has used the word legal or legally, I think, twice when it comes to Aledo gaining athletes. Am I missing something that in the past Aledo was accused of doing something illegally? If you can't understand something as simple as what a good or bad coach is then I definitely don't expect you to understand things like talent acquisition. Quote
Reagan Posted February 9, 2022 Report Posted February 9, 2022 5 minutes ago, Cougar14.2 said: If you can't understand something as simple as what a good or bad coach is then I definitely don't expect you to understand things like talent acquisition. HA! You got busted for being dramatic! LOL!! PS -- I don't blame you for being envious of Aledo! Let me see: 56-21 😃😃 Quote
Cougar14.2 Posted February 9, 2022 Report Posted February 9, 2022 2 minutes ago, Reagan said: HA! You got busted for being dramatic! LOL!! I didn't dramatize anything. Watch the documentary. Aledo got two transfers that were ruled eligible. The qb they beat Crosby with was a transfer and was ruled eligible, meaning they legally acquired the kids. This isn't string theory bro. Quote
MackLewis Posted February 9, 2022 Report Posted February 9, 2022 On 1/31/2022 at 3:48 PM, Reagan said: I'll ask you: Did the "personel" just show up when Surratt at Carthage (after 84 years of no State Title) and Buchanan at Aledo showed up? Of course not!! They were there before. The coach was the difference! Again, letting a coach go, it all depends on where you set the bar. My bar is high. The PNG coach had 12 years. Does that mean he was treated unfairly? I wouldn't think so. But, I knew after 7-8 years that a State Title wasn't in PNG's future. Maybe the Superintendent and board members realized the same thing. Like I've said before -- if one's expectations are low, then they'l be met EVERY time! If all schools had the talent, resources, and other advantages that Carthage has, then I would agree. Seven years is a “fair” amount of time to win a title. Don’t mean a coach should be ran off if he don’t win one though. Should a coach at Hardin-Jefferson, Orangefield, or Shephard be held to the same expectations as a coach at Carthage, or WO-S? Surratt is a great coach and has built a dynasty. But let’s not act like he would duplicate that success at the schools mentioned above. Sometimes it takes the right coach at the right place to do amazing things. Mr. Buddy Garrity 1 Quote
AledoAlumni Posted February 10, 2022 Report Posted February 10, 2022 3 hours ago, Cougar14.2 said: You're never going to convince me parents with star football players are going pass up schools like Euless Trinity, which is the same distance from Ft. Worth as Aledo, to come there for a couple extra playoff games or the debate team. Like I said though, however the players end up there is obviously above board so more power to y'all. I'm not trying to convince you of anything. And clearly there are parents that prefer what Aledo has to offer vs Martin. Thats why they moved to Aledo. Separation Scientist 1 Quote
AledoAlumni Posted February 10, 2022 Report Posted February 10, 2022 2 hours ago, Cougar14.2 said: I didn't dramatize anything. Watch the documentary. Aledo got two transfers that were ruled eligible. The qb they beat Crosby with was a transfer and was ruled eligible, meaning they legally acquired the kids. This isn't string theory bro. Families are seeking out Aledo. Aledo is not out seeking out families. Personally I wish they never sold the Walsh ranch and never started all the housing developments these last last 15 years. agrfall1970 and Separation Scientist 2 Quote
Reagan Posted February 10, 2022 Report Posted February 10, 2022 3 hours ago, MackLewis said: If all schools had the talent, resources, and other advantages that Carthage has, then I would agree. Seven years is a “fair” amount of time to win a title. Don’t mean a coach should be ran off if he don’t win one though. Should a coach at Hardin-Jefferson, Orangefield, or Shephard be held to the same expectations as a coach at Carthage, or WO-S? Surratt is a great coach and has built a dynasty. But let’s not act like he would duplicate that success at the schools mentioned above. Sometimes it takes the right coach at the right place to do amazing things. I’ll respond more later. But, did I understand you to say that your Father was on the varsity football staff under Malone? Quote
Horton Posted February 13, 2022 Report Posted February 13, 2022 On 2/9/2022 at 4:15 PM, MackLewis said: If all schools had the talent, resources, and other advantages that Carthage has, then I would agree. Seven years is a “fair” amount of time to win a title. Don’t mean a coach should be ran off if he don’t win one though. Should a coach at Hardin-Jefferson, Orangefield, or Shephard be held to the same expectations as a coach at Carthage, or WO-S? Surratt is a great coach and has built a dynasty. But let’s not act like he would duplicate that success at the schools mentioned above. Sometimes it takes the right coach at the right place to do amazing things. Surratt and staff would win a state championship at any school mentioned above. He is the best coach in the state of Texas. A master at finding the opposing teams weaknesses. Carthage has not grown in size in 50 years. Has always had athletes but never won a state championship until coach Surratt got there. 8 state championships and 11 semifinals since 2007. Can you imagine what that staff could do at a school with 3 and 4 deep at every position. we at Carthage are very Blessed to have coach Surratt. Thankful we will have him at least 4 more years. His son is an elite QB and will be a freshman this year. I predict he will be the Dawg starter for 3 years and that class is loaded with size and speed. Reagan 1 Quote
agrfall1970 Posted February 13, 2022 Report Posted February 13, 2022 On 2/9/2022 at 6:12 PM, aledoalumni said: Families are seeking out Aledo. Aledo is not out seeking out families. Personally I wish they never sold the Walsh ranch and never started all the housing developments these last last 15 years. Was the Dean Ranch in Aledio ISD? Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.