PNG first TD was a fumble recovered by Montgomery that ref missed bad!!!!!!!

[spudaroo]

I am a retired coach with two State champioship rings,  but the officating in the PNG/Montgomery was as bad as I have ever seen. Watched film of game plus was at game and PNG first TD #15 fumbled before crossing the plane and montgomery recovered in the endzone on 4th down. Line judge calls TD before fumble. Very, very obvious ball was fumbled before breaking the plain. Difference in ball game and a chance for district championship is 6 pts.  Unbelieveable this is the best that can be found for A HUGE 5A Game and the refrees make the difference in who wins. Takes the game out of the kids hands

[aki1994]

Go file a complaint. You know what was also missed that play? The kid making the tackle had him by the facemask and completely pulled his helmet off doing so. Fumble no fumble. If it all was called right. First and goal PNG. 

[spudaroo]

21 minutes ago, aki1994 said:

Go file a complaint. You know what was also missed that play? The kid making the tackle had him by the facemask and completely pulled his helmet off doing so. Fumble no fumble. If it all was called right. First and goal PNG. 

No face mask on that play See the kids helment the whole play. Kid was hit low if you want to see whole video!!! 

[NDN1982]

Who cares????? Game over life goes on 

[spudaroo]

17 minutes ago, NDN1982 said:

Who cares????? Game over life goes on 

WHO cares????? The 28 seniors at Montgomery High school who had a chance for a Possible district championship and Officals who are part time employee's making decision for people whose livelihood's depend on them. (Coaches)

[PNG4LIFE91]

So, file a complaint with TASO because complaining about it on here isn’t going to accomplish ANYTHING…which you should KNOW being a retired coach with 2 State Championships and all.  

[NDN1982]

Absolutely ridiculous 🙄 😒 

[Lamar1996]

56 minutes ago, spudaroo said:

WHO cares????? The 28 seniors at Montgomery High school who had a chance for a Possible district championship and Officals who are part time employee's making decision for people whose livelihood's depend on them. (Coaches)

I didn’t know that one little play changed the entire outcome of the game.  I also won national football championships sitting on my couch.  🤣🤣

[spudaroo]

TASO will agree and give a public acknowledgement and say they were wrong and game stands. Been there done that.  And look up 2006 -2007 state champions and find the team that went 28-0 those two years.

 

[pine curtain]

1 hour ago, spudaroo said:

TASO will agree and give a public acknowledgement and say they were wrong and game stands. Been there done that.  And look up 2006 -2007 state champions and find the team that went 28-0 those two years.

 

And I bet you never had a call go your way......

You should have stopped the game and told the officials they were wrong and to change it. 

[png9mon]

1 hour ago, spudaroo said:

TASO will agree and give a public acknowledgement and say they were wrong and game stands. Been there done that.  And look up 2006 -2007 state champions and find the team that went 28-0 those two years.

 

It has been a bad year for referees all year long.  For and against our team as well.   Unfortunately referees are human, mistakes are made.  As fans it will burn your butt when the call goes against you.  As Christians we must forgive and move on.  If life was perfect no high school football would ever be played.  Remember,  they are just boys playing a game, and boys make are sometimes going to make mistakes as well. Hoping the Bears, and the referees move forward with blessings of focus and peace.

[OC07]

I am a retired coach also, i hope this doesn't make my point invalid because i don't have 2 State Championships, only a couple of district championships, but from where I was sitting it looked liked the runner got in on the first or second try, which was missed by the official. It should have never got to 4th down. I am sure you couldn't see that looking through those rose colored glasses.

As a retired coach, especially one with 2 State Championships, I am really surprised you decided to take this up on a message board.

[1970]

53 minutes ago, OC07 said:

I am a retired coach also, i hope this doesn't make my point invalid because i don't have 2 State Championships, only a couple of district championships, but from where I was sitting it looked liked the runner got in on the first or second try, which was missed by the official. It should have never got to 4th down. I am sure you couldn't see that looking through those rose colored glasses.

As a retired coach, especially one with 2 State Championships, I am really surprised you decided to take this up on a message board.

This thread is indeed ridiculous. But I've noticed all season, the refs reluctance to signal TD with the goal line pile ups. I forget which game, either Laporte or MLC, Coach Joseph got really mad when the pile clearly crossed the goal line and the refs wouldn't signal TD. 

[FrodoNDN]

Wasn't there a backward pass fumble that wasn't called? 

[png9mon]

7 minutes ago, FrodoNDN said:

Wasn't there a backward pass fumble that wasn't called? 

Yep, obviously a lateral.

[pine curtain]

2 minutes ago, png9mon said:

Yep, obviously a lateral.

what is an obvious lateral?

 

[1970]

30 minutes ago, pine curtain said:

what is an obvious lateral?

 

Need to know basis only, unless you're a retired coach. 

[aki1994]

15 hours ago, spudaroo said:

No face mask on that play See the kids helment the whole play. Kid was hit low if you want to see whole video!!! 

Explain to me how he went low when hi s helmet is above the PNG runners helmet? Just give it up. 

[Right99JOH]

19 hours ago, spudaroo said:

I am a retired coach with two State champioship rings,  but the officating in the PNG/Montgomery was as bad as I have ever seen. Watched film of game plus was at game and PNG first TD #15 fumbled before crossing the plane and montgomery recovered in the endzone on 4th down. Line judge calls TD before fumble. Very, very obvious ball was fumbled before breaking the plain. Difference in ball game and a chance for district championship is 6 pts.  Unbelieveable this is the best that can be found for A HUGE 5A Game and the refrees make the difference in who wins. Takes the game out of the kids hands

Suck it up buttercup and dry the tears

[Who That]

It is what it is. Don't know about district games. But I" do believe in playoffs games with plays like this they should be reviewed. 

[Stattrax]

On 11/3/2024 at 12:29 PM, spudaroo said:

I am a retired coach with two State champioship rings,  but the officating in the PNG/Montgomery was as bad as I have ever seen. Watched film of game plus was at game and PNG first TD #15 fumbled before crossing the plane and montgomery recovered in the endzone on 4th down. Line judge calls TD before fumble. Very, very obvious ball was fumbled before breaking the plain. Difference in ball game and a chance for district championship is 6 pts.  Unbelieveable this is the best that can be found for A HUGE 5A Game and the refrees make the difference in who wins. Takes the game out of the kids hands

I am a retired fantasy football owner. With 6 Super Bowl wins. And I will say this. Maybe the funniest post I have ever seen on here. I guess this is the Montgomery Mentality…….

[LTFALCON]

On 11/3/2024 at 12:29 PM, spudaroo said:

I am a retired coach with two State champioship rings,  but the officating in the PNG/Montgomery was as bad as I have ever seen. Watched film of game plus was at game and PNG first TD #15 fumbled before crossing the plane and montgomery recovered in the endzoneon 4th down. Line judge calls TD before fumble. Very, very obvious ball was fumbled before breaking the plain. Difference in ball game and a chance for district championship is 6 pts.  Unbelieveable this is the best that can be found for A HUGE 5A Game and the refrees make the difference in who wins. Takes the game out of the kids hands

Correct me if I am wrong, don't the coaches agree on the crew way in advance? Both coaches have to agree, correct? So, coaches probably picked what they thought were the best available for the game. Might have used them in the past and had good luck with the crew. Without the instant replay in HS football, officiating will play a factor. Calls like this could be reviewed and get it right, like they do in NCAA. But that would cost money and dont think we are there yet for HS regular season games!

[pngfan316]

We still recovered it in the endzone so it don't matter🤷🏼‍♂️🤷🏼‍♂️

[setxathlete14]

BC would hire you as a private investigator for their games

[jimbob82]

Spudaroo, must have didn't get the memo.  All mid county teams ie:  PNG:NED,  GET a FREE touchdown, BEFORE the teams get off the bus.  It's always been this way...Just ask around....