Is Dirk a top 5 player in the NBA?

[Guest baseball25]

Give me yalls thoughts..

[Guest nostradamus]

no

[Guest baseball25]

name your top 5

[Guest nostradamus]

1.  Lebron

2.  Kobe

3.  D Wade

4.  Dwight Howard

5.  Chris Paul

[bacbone9]

i dont een think he top 10

[Lazeek]

Heck no he is  not top 5....................he is white!!!!!!!! ;D ;D ;D

[Guest nostradamus]

bacbone....I may disagree about top 10.....I would be interested to see your top 10 if you think he is not top 10

[bacbone9]

bacbone....I may disagree about top 10.....I would be interested to see your top 10 if you think he is not top 10

1. Lebron

2. Kobe

3. Wade

4. Howard

5. Paul

6. Pierce

7. Anthony

8. Roy

9. Ming

10. Duncan

Might be in the wrong order but thats my top 10

[Guest nostradamus]

I'd have to put Dirk ahead of Anthony, Ming, Duncan, and possibly Roy

[bacbone9]

I'd have to put Dirk ahead of Anthony, Ming, Duncan, and possibly Roy

naw nos....dirk not better than them..i disagree. Roy is the man

[Lazeek]

No Amare Stoudamire in the top 10????  You can't be serious!!!!!

[bacbone9]

No Amare Stoudamire in the top 10????  You can't be serious!!!!!

he been out all year

[Lazeek]

He missed the last month of the season or so............he is one of the best when healthy!!!!!!

[wos08]

1. Kobe

2. Lebron

3. Wade

4. Howard

5. Deron Williams

6. CP3

7. Carmelo

8. Durant

9. Chauncey

10. Brandon Roy

[Guest spinks]

1. Kobe

2. Lebron

3. Wade

4. Howard

5. Deron Williams

6. CP3

7. Carmelo

8. Durant

9. Chauncey

10. Brandon Roy

Where is Steve Nash in this conversation?

[AggiesAreWe]

1. Kobe

2. Lebron

3. Wade

4. Howard

5. Deron Williams

6. CP3

7. Carmelo

8. Durant

9. Chauncey

10. Brandon Roy

Where is Steve Nash in this conversation?

I know where he is, but I won't say. ;D

[dayton]

1. Kobe

2. Lebron

3. Wade

4. Howard

5. Deron Williams

6. CP3

7. Carmelo

8. Durant

9. Chauncey

10. Brandon Roy

I couldn't include those two in front of Nash and Nowitzki just purely off experience (especially in big games) and leadership.

[Guest spinks]

1. Kobe

2. Lebron

3. Wade

4. Howard

5. Deron Williams

6. CP3

7. Carmelo

8. Durant

9. Chauncey

10. Brandon Roy

Where is Steve Nash in this conversation?

I know where he is, but I won't say. ;D

pretty good one aaw!

[bacbone9]

He missed the last month of the season or so............he is one of the best when healthy!!!!!!

true staement...that just shoiws how far Dirk is down the list

[shorttexas1]

Dirk is not top 5 and he is reaching for top ten

We all knoew the top three. But all of you forget just who Tim Duncan is.... I would count on him to lead me to a big win before I even look Howards way! And you all forget just who Paul Piece is!

James

Bryant

Wade

Duncan

Howard

Paul

Pierce

Williams

Anthony

Ming

Roy

Parker

DIRK  Yeah about 13 is right!

Igudola, Granger, R. Jefferson, Al Jefferson, Boozer, Billups, Kevin Martin, Devin Harris, Chris Bosh, and Rip could all push him for that spot!

[Lazeek]

Short.............no love for Stoudamire either!!!!!

WOW is all that I can say with you guys opinion on the Top 10!!!!!!

[bullets13]

he's top 10.  at times, he plays like a top-5 player, but he's not consistent enough.  for instance, he's been a top 5 player in the playoffs this year, IMO.

[shorttexas1]

You know what... my Bad... Stoudemire above Dirk too... He is more like top fifteen then top five.  Stoudemire is WEAK on D and has lost a step since the injury.  The more I think about it I want to move Dirk around 20! 

James

Bryant

Wade

Duncan

Howard

Paul

Pierce

Williams

Anthony

Ming

Roy

Parker

Stoudemire

Garnett

Billups

Bosh

Igudola

Granger

Boozer

Rip

Devin Harris

K. Martin

R. Jefferson

Al Jefferson

Steve Nash

DIRK

I feel much better about this list.  Artest, Rondo, and Aldridge starting to give him a run for his money too!  McGrady is still better than Dirk!

[Gabe]

Nobody gives love to D. Rose??

My top 5

1. Lebron

2. Kobe

3. Wade

4. CP3

5. Duncan

[wos08]

Ah forgot about Pierce and Duncan

4.Duncan

5.Howard

6.Deron Williams

7.CP3

8.Pierce

9.Carmelo

10.Durant

11.Chauncey

Gasol would be in my top 15, but he's getting punked this series