Is Dirk a top 5 player in the NBA?

[Gabe]

If I did top 10, Derrick Rose would have to be in there, at least top 15

[HJ-HawkHecklers409]

everyone who is NOT putting dirk in their top 10 are ignorant IDIOTS...

Its

1. Lebron

2. D-wade

3. Kobe

4. Melo

5. Howard

6. Howard

7. Yao

8. Dirk

9. Duncan

10. Billups/Ray allen

of course none of the black ppl will put nash or dirk in their top 10, even though they're two of the best players to come through the NBA... Ignorance..

[shorttexas1]

everyone who is NOT putting dirk in their top 10 are ignorant IDIOTS...

Its

1. Lebron

2. D-wade

3. Kobe

4. Melo

5. Howard

6. Howard

7. Yao

8. Dirk

9. Duncan

10. Billups/Ray allen

of course none of the black ppl will put nash or dirk in their top 10, even though they're two of the best players to come through the NBA... Ignorance..

You have tbe kidding me dude...  Its 2009, racism is dead!  I have no problem with him being WHITE.. I am still a BIG Bird fan!  Hornaseck and Stockton too!(tough guys) But you white folk always looking for reverse racism?  My problem with Dirk is the same problem yall have with Tmac!!! He is soft!  7' big man that can only shoot, CAN'T PLAY DEFENSE, and will never win the big one!!!... Same problem nash has! 

[Bucof2010]

Its a joke to not have Garnett in the top ten especially if you have pierce in there. I dont even think Duncan touches Garnett.