jdawg03 Posted November 23, 2006 Report Posted November 23, 2006 11 pt taken by Ronnie Comeaux of Pineland Texas...Killed in Pineland, about 25 miles north of Jasper
preacher Posted November 23, 2006 Report Posted November 23, 2006 What a deer!!!!!! Congrats. :shock: :shock: :shock:
tommyjean Posted November 28, 2006 Report Posted November 28, 2006 in all honesty ive got a big one in my pasture that will give it a run for its money and on my deer lease weve got one that will score about 180 or 190 boon and crockett and its in sabine county
big_robes49 Posted December 6, 2006 Report Posted December 6, 2006 wow! :shock: :shock: :shock: :shock: :shock:
gringo Posted December 7, 2006 Report Posted December 7, 2006 Nice deer, what did he score? Looks to go around 140 BC, but maybe more cause I cant see the 11th point.
CATS80 Posted December 7, 2006 Report Posted December 7, 2006 FROM LOOKING AT THE PIC I SCORE IT AT AROUND 162 AND THATS JUST FROM THE POINTS I SEE. ITS HARD TO JUDGE FROM A PIC BUT I BET IM CLOSE. I GUESS THE 11TH POINT IS PROBABLY A KICKER
tvc184 Posted December 7, 2006 Report Posted December 7, 2006 FROM LOOKING AT THE PIC I SCORE IT AT AROUND 162 AND THATS JUST FROM THE POINTS I SEE. ITS HARD TO JUDGE FROM A PIC BUT I BET IM CLOSE. I GUESS THE 11TH POINT IS PROBABLY A KICKER I was going to guess about 155 but from the looks of it, it could certainly be larger.
gringo Posted December 7, 2006 Report Posted December 7, 2006 FROM LOOKING AT THE PIC I SCORE IT AT AROUND 162 AND THATS JUST FROM THE POINTS I SEE. ITS HARD TO JUDGE FROM A PIC BUT I BET IM CLOSE. I GUESS THE 11TH POINT IS PROBABLY A KICKER I dont see it CATS80 - rescored and still cant quite get to 150 I got him as follows - 28" mass 42" mains 18" spread 60" tines (and thats probably high) 148" total w/o the kicker that I cant find. Still, a great deer !
BucketSitR Posted December 8, 2006 Report Posted December 8, 2006 Wrong, I scored it..... Went 165 and change. The right G2 is broken off at the kicker base. That is the kicker that you see. That loses about 7 inches. Unbroken would have been 172. Picture does not do deer justice.
gringo Posted December 8, 2006 Report Posted December 8, 2006 Wrong' date=' I scored it..... Went 165 and change. The right G2 is broken off at the kicker base. That is the kicker that you see. That loses about 7 inches. Unbroken would have been 172. [b']Picture does not do deer justice.[/quote] I guess not! What were the measurements?
tvc184 Posted December 8, 2006 Report Posted December 8, 2006 I figured that your spread and main beams are short changed. Maybe some on the mass. Hard to tell without another angle or side shot.
gringo Posted December 8, 2006 Report Posted December 8, 2006 I figured that your spread and main beams are short changed. Maybe some on the mass. Hard to tell without another angle or side shot.[/quote] True. But, even if you give him 23" main beams and an inside spread of 20" that still leaves me 9" short on the tines. Maybe BucketSitR can give us all the measurements.
BucketSitR Posted December 8, 2006 Report Posted December 8, 2006 This is the rough score. spread 17" Mass 32 Lenghts 67" Mains 46 160 1/8Typical 5 6/8 Kicker 165 7/8 NT 5 1/8 difference 160 6/8 NT Net Nice Deer
gringo Posted December 8, 2006 Report Posted December 8, 2006 Sweeeeeeeeeeeet! He must have carried good mass all the way (cant tell from pic but I guessed 5,4,3,2) and I mssied his G2's and G3's by a mile :oops: How big were his G2's and 3's?
BucketSitR Posted December 8, 2006 Report Posted December 8, 2006 4 3/8, 4 1/8, 4 4/8, 3 6/8 Mass carried 5 4/8, 12 1/8, 10 4/8, 6 6/8 Tines 5 inches deduct ain't bad for that many inches. The worst was for the broke G2. Gave him a hard time. Should have let him breed more!!!!!!!!!!!
gringo Posted December 8, 2006 Report Posted December 8, 2006 Great mass all the way out and exceptional G4s! Real nice buck.
big_buck_hunter Posted December 9, 2006 Report Posted December 9, 2006 FROM LOOKING AT THE PIC I SCORE IT AT AROUND 162 AND THATS JUST FROM THE POINTS I SEE. ITS HARD TO JUDGE FROM A PIC BUT I BET IM CLOSE. I GUESS THE 11TH POINT IS PROBABLY A KICKER Hey I have some pictures that show the horns better. It scored 165 7/8 I can't figure out how to post them. Send me a PM and I will send 'em to you.
big_buck_hunter Posted December 15, 2006 Report Posted December 15, 2006 Hey I have some pictures that show the horns better. It scored 165 7/8 I can't figure out how to post them. Send me a PM and I will send 'em to you. Try this link and let me know if it works.
gringo Posted December 15, 2006 Report Posted December 15, 2006 Now thats better. First pic in series shows mass and mains much better. Beautiful deer.
STINGER Posted December 18, 2006 Report Posted December 18, 2006 Great buck........ My brother killed a 169 non-typical in Sabine County this year too..... It did have about 15 inches of deductions though leaving him at 154 typical... I have seen Ronnie's deer pics before and trust me he is most definatley a 165.....
Recommended Posts